Residential Roofing Materials in Chicago

Choosing the right roofing shingles in Chicago, IL is crucial due to the region's varied and often harsh weather conditions, which include heavy rains, gusty winds, snow, and ice. Premium-quality shingles provide essential durability, protecting your home from the elements while enhancing energy efficiency by helping to maintain comfortable indoor temperatures. Opting for top-notch materials not only prolongs your roof's lifespan but also mitigates the risk of frequent repairs and maintenance costs that can add up quickly. Furthermore, the ideal shingles can significantly boost your home's curb appeal, consequently increasing its market value. At Lee Island Roofing, our experienced contractors guide you through a comprehensive selection process, ensuring you choose shingles that perfectly complement your home’s design and can withstand the unpredictable weather patterns characteristic of Chicagoland. We understand the importance of making an informed decision and are committed to helping you achieve the best results for your roofing project.

Learn More

Residential Roofing Materials

One of the most commonly asked questions concerning roof replacement is, "What is the expected lifespan of my new investment?" This is a vital consideration for homeowners, as it has a direct effect on long-term value and maintenance expenses. However, the answer to this question largely hinges on the materials chosen for the roofing project. With the extensive array of roofing options currently available on the market, navigating this decision can often feel overwhelming and potentially expensive. Understanding the distinctions in durability, aesthetics, and cost can further add to the complexity. Fortunately, Comet Roofing Contractors are here to assist you in making this crucial choice. We will delve into the advantages and disadvantages of each roofing option, providing you with all the necessary information to make a well-informed decision that caters to your needs, preferences, and budget.

3-Tab Asphalt Shingles

15 to 50 years

Asphalt 3-Tab Shingles vs. Architectural Asphalt Shingles - The Asphalt Shingle family offers a diverse range of options, mainly divided into two categories: Asphalt 3-Tab Shingles and Architectural Asphalt Shingles. Both types are made with a flexible fiberglass or organic base, which is then layered with asphalt and granules to improve their resilience against environmental challenges.


3-Tab Shingles - 3-Tab Shingles are highly popular and often the most economical option. They feature a distinct design with an exposed area showcasing three identically sized tabs symmetrically arranged across your roof. With a wide selection of color options, this type of shingle generally lasts up to 20 years.


Architectural Asphalt Shingles - Architectural shingles offer superior durability when compared to three-tab shingles, featuring a multi-dimensional, textured design that resembles wood shakes or slate. Their increased thickness allows architectural shingles to endure for up to 50 years.

Average Cost

Wood Shingles

25 - 30 years

Wood Shingles vs Wood Shakes - Both wood shingles and shakes are crafted from a variety of timber, providing a rustic charm and natural appeal. To maintain their durability of 20-30 years, regular maintenance every 2-5 years is crucial to prevent issues such as rotting and cracking.


Wood Shingles - Wood shingles are carefully crafted and shaped from various tree species, including treated pine and redwood. Their installation and aesthetic closely mirror the popular 3-Tab Asphalt Shingle, resulting in a roof that showcases a uniform and symmetrical visual appeal.


Wood Shakes - Shakes boast a thicker profile and unique appearance, with each piece differing from the next, offering a broader range of design possibilities. White Cedar is a popular choice that beautifully complements this distinctive style.

Average Cost

Metal Roofing

20 - 50 years

Metal Roofing - Metal roofs present an exquisite array of designs, materials, colors, and shapes, providing homeowners with a wealth of options for customization to match their personal tastes and architectural styles. The materials available for metal roofing encompass robust choices like copper, tin, stainless steel, aluminum, zinc, and several others, each offering distinct characteristics and advantages. The price of metal roofs can vary widely depending on the selected material, chosen design, and installation method, with some options being more economical than others. Among the favored roofing selections are Corrugated panels, Standing Seam, and Shingles, each imparting unique aesthetic qualities and practical benefits. Notably, Standing Seam installation is recognized for its remarkable protection against harsh weather, while Copper is distinguished by its impressive durability and corrosion resistance. Moreover, it's crucial to assess the weight of the roofing materials before installation, as this might require additional reinforcement of the roof structure to guarantee stability and safety. With adequate care and upkeep, a metal roof can astonishingly last for up to a century, marking it as a prudent long-term investment for any homeowner!

Average Cost

Composite Shingles

40 - 50 years

Composite Roofing - Composite roofing shingles are skillfully engineered from a wide range of materials, including wood, plastic, asphalt, and laminate, which combine to form a strong and adaptable product. The installation of these shingles is simple, making them a favored option for both homeowners and builders. They are mainly designed to replicate traditional roofing styles, effectively imitating the look of classic materials such as wooden shingles, asphalt tiles, or ceramic roofing. A notable advantage of composite roofing is its remarkable lifespan, often extending up to 50 years with minimal maintenance, positioning them as a sound long-term investment for property owners. Although the initial cost of composite materials and their installation tends to exceed that of conventional asphalt shingles, they prove to be a more budget-friendly alternative compared to pricier options like wood or tile roofing. Beyond their visual appeal, composite shingles provide durability and resistance to harsh weather conditions, further solidifying their worth as a roofing solution.

Average Cost

Clay Shingles

50+ years

Concrete, Clay, and Terracotta Tile Roofing – Each of these roofing options exudes a classic rustic appeal, yet they differ notably in terms of cost, lifespan, and particular uses. Among these, Concrete Tiles emerge as the most economical selection, readily offered in a captivating range of colors and styles to match various architectural tastes; however, they do have a significant susceptibility to mold, which can create maintenance issues over time. Clay tiles, positioned at the high end of the price range, provide a breathtaking variety of colors and designs with exceptional durability, often rendering them a valuable investment for homeowners seeking both longevity and aesthetic beauty. In contrast, Terracotta tiles fall within a mid-range price category and are recognized for their impressive heat resistance, making them especially favored in warmer climates where sun exposure is a concern. However, their effectiveness tends to wane in colder areas, potentially limiting their prevalence and appeal in such regions. It's worth noting that all three options are expected to last over 50 years, making them attractive long-term choices for those looking to invest in a robust roof.

Average Cost

Slate Shingles

50+ years

Slate roof shingles are an outstanding choice for roofing, renowned for their natural beauty, exceptional durability, and impressive lifespan. Made from natural stone, these shingles offer an elegant look that not only elevates a home’s curb appeal but also imparts a sense of sophistication to its overall architectural design. Slate is highly resistant to fire, harsh weather conditions, and temperature changes, enabling it to last for over a century with proper care and maintenance. Although the initial cost may be higher than that of other roofing materials, the long-term advantages of durability and minimal maintenance make slate shingles a smart and valuable investment for homeowners. Additionally, slate shingles are ideal for those seeking a classic, high-quality roofing option, as they harmoniously integrate with various home styles and can significantly enhance property value over time. Their distinctive appearance also guarantees that no two roofs are identical, ensuring that every installation is genuinely unique.

Average Cost

Comet Roofing Contractors work with trusted, top-quality brands you can rely on!

Comet Roofing contractors confidently rely on esteemed roofing material brands such as GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed, TAMKO, and IKO due to their proven durability, superior quality, and consistent reliability—qualities that are essential for navigating the unpredictable weather patterns frequently encountered in Illinois, especially in the Chicagoland area. These trusted brands deliver exceptional protection against a wide range of weather challenges, including heavy rain, strong winds, ice, snow, and fluctuating seasonal temperatures, ensuring that homes remain safe and sound in all conditions. With features that encompass cutting-edge technology, robust warranties, and improved energy efficiency, these materials help reduce long-term maintenance expenses for homeowners. By selecting these top-rated products, roofs are better prepared to endure the harsh conditions typical of Chicago, while also enhancing curb appeal and raising overall property value. Homeowners can rest assured knowing they are investing in materials that provide lasting performance and peace of mind for years to come.

Contact us for questions